1Beveridge model
healthcare provided and financed by gov (from taxes)
2countries with Beveridge model
Great Britain, Spain, most of Scandinavia, New Zealand, Hong Kong, Cuba
3Bismarck model
healthcare provided as insurance paid jointly by employers and employees (payroll deduction)
4countries with Bismarck mode
Germany, France, Belgium, Netherlands, Japan, Switzerland, most of the US
5National Health Insurance model (NHI)
healthcare provided by private providers/hospital, paid by gov insurance program (all citizens contributes)
6countries with NHI model
Canada, Taiwan, South Korea
7- Pt’s must see general provider (GP) for specialist referral
- GPs are paid extra if their pt’s are kept healthy
- Hospitals compete for NHS funds (good quality care is incentivized)
healthcare in Great Britain
8- Pros: low admin costs, no bills for pt
- Cons: long wait time, limited GP options
pros/cons healthcare in Great Britain
9- Ppl get insurance from work or community fund (public assistance if can't afford)
- Everyone is required to have health insurance
- Ministry of Health negotiates with Dr’s for every procedure price
- Can see a specialist without PCP referral
healthcare in Japan
10- Pros: low pt bills, can go to any specialist whenever
- Cons: hospitals have low funds, no PCP to check how often pt gets care, lack of medical homes
pros/cons healthcare in Japan
11- Ppl get insurance from 200 private, nonprofit “sickness funds” (insurance)
- Insurance cannot deny coverage based on preexisting conditions
- Insurance compete for pts, more members = more $
- Insurance negotiates with Dr’s for procedures
- Can see a specialist without PCP referral (but costs $$$)
healthcare in Germany
12- Pros: low copay, can’t be denied on preexisting cond., cheap malpractice insurance for Dr’s, free med schooling is common
- Cons: Dr’s are underpaid (bc single-payment system), the rich can get for for-profit plans (sees Dr’s faster bc more $$)
pros/cons healthcare in Germany
13- Ppl have a smart card (stores med history, bills gov-insurer, monitors care standards)
- Only 1 gov-run insurance
- Premiums are split btwn pt and employer (gov assistance at flat rates if needed)
- Veterans are fully covered
- Greatly extended coverage to the uninsured and decreased growth of healthcare spending
healthcare in Taiwan
14- Pros: lowest admin cost globally, can see any Dr w/o referral, everyone has a smart card
- Cons: hospitals have low funds (gov not spending enough $$ on healthcare)
pros/cons healthcare in Taiwan
15- Everyone is required to have health insurance (public assistance if can’t afford prems)
- Insurance can't profit on basic care or cherry-pick low risk pts
- Allowed to profit off supplemental insurance
- Insurance negotiates with Dr’s for procedure costs
- Gov sets drug prices
healthcare in Switzerland
16- Pros: can’t be fully denied if not low risk
- Cons: 2nd most expensive healthcare in world, drug prices still high, no required GP to check how often pt gets care (but $ incentives if pt uses them)
pros/cons healthcare in Switzerland
17unanticipated pure risk (5x)
risk outcomes that are insurable/covered, must include the following–
1. Chance of occurrence can be accurately estimated
2. Event must be irregular (on individual basis)
3. Event must result in a substantial loss
4. Said loss must be measurable
5. Person with loss should have insurance plan
18Adverse Selection
ppl with low risk of illness less likely to buy insurance, results in pool of high risk and cost pts
19Adverse Selection solution
- Group policies
- Waiting periods
- Medical underwriting (incentivizes low risk pts)
- Coverage limitations (lowers risk in high risk pts)
20Incentives To Create Losses
- Dr’s can create demand for services they supply (especially physician-owned hospitals)
- Can order unnecessary procedures for $$
21Incentives To Create Losses solution
- Capitation
- Diagnostic related groups (DRGs)
- Global payment models
22Supplier-Induced Demand
- Supplier can create demand for services they supply
- Drug/procedure ads targeted towards pts can convince unnecessary demands
23Supplier-Induced Demand solution
- Utilization management
- Prior authorizations from Dr’s can ensure pt truly needs the drug
24Primary Agent Problem
- One entity makes decision on behalf of another person
- Dr’s makes clinical decision for pt, but isn’t the one paying for it (might not consider financial constraints)
25Primary Agent Problem solution
Price transparency and education (so pt is aware to decide)
26Moral Hazard
- When price of service decreases, demand increases
- Ppl with health coverage may have more risky behavior
27Moral Hazard solution
- Cost sharing
- Pt still responsible for costs, bills can incentivize unrisky behavior
28Rand Health insurance experiment
- RCT experiment, assessed effects of cost sharing on health
- Methods: participants assigned to 1 of 5 plans w/ diff co-ins (cost sharing vs fee-for-service models)
- Results: pts with cost sharing plans had less Dr visits, hospitalizations, prescriptions, treatments per yr, worries; no change in health
29The Oregon Experiment (2008)
- natural experiment, assessed effects of having health coverage
- Methods: 10k pts were enrolled in the Oregon Health Plan in a lottery system
- Results: higher use of preventive care services, Dr visits, happiness; no change in health
30Scope of practice
procedures/actions a healthcare professional is allowed to do under their license
31Collaborative prescribing
allows provider to delegate certain prescribing duties to pharmacists under negotiated conditions
32Collaborative Practice Agreements (CPAs)
defines the specific prescribing duties pharmacists are allowed to do, agreed by the provider and pharmacist
33Single participant CPAs
agreement only applies to the individuals present at the agreement meeting (can be more than 1 pharmacist/provider)
34Multiple participant CPAs
agreement can apply to everyone (pharmacist/provider) in the organization
35differences in Oregon law on collaborative prescribing
- CPAs are called CDTMs (collaborative drug therapy management agreements)
- CDTMs in Oregon are “Patient-Specific CPAs” and requires documentation of pt referral to pharmacist for each person
36Autonomous prescribing
certain drugs/devices pharmacist can prescribe without a CPA/provider approval
37Oregon House Bill 2397
- Formed Public Health and Formulary Advisory Committee
- Makes recs to Board on what drugs/devices pharmacists can prescribe/dispense
- You can submit a form with pharmacy suggestions/ideas to the Board to consider
38Medicare advantage (MA)
allows Medicare pt’s to receive their benefits from a private plan, instead of Original Medicare (FFS)
39Fee-For-Service (FFS)
- Insurance company pays Dr for each service pt used
- ex: EGHPs, exchange plans, Original Medicare, some Medicaid
40Prospective Payment System (PPS)
- Insurance company pays fixed/flat fee per pt (even if service not used)
- ex: capitation, DRGs
41Value-Based Payment System (VBP)
- Insurance company pays Dr for each service, but payment depends on quality/cost of care
- ex: bundled payment system, ACOs, pay for performance
42Five star rating program
- rates the quality of care for each health insurance plans, affects reimbursement
- All posted ratings for the year are based on data from 2 years before
- Score is calculated thru several topics (48 total)
43Five star rating program purpose
1. Allows you to compare health plans
2. Gives insurance companies access to special enrollment periods (can enroll more pts)
3. Used to calculate bonus payments for high quality plans (gov gives more
4. Used to penalize low quality plans
44Capitation payment
fixed payment CMS (fed gov) pays the MA plan per month per pt enrolled, amount depends on base rate
45Base rate
- the $$ CMS (fed gov) pays the private insurance company monthly for covering Medicare patients
- $$ amount is the lower amount btwn plan bid and benchmark
46Plan bid
- $$ the insurance company asks for providing coverage for that plan/pt
- Accounts for the plan’s estimated administrative costs, medical service costs, and profits
- Admin. costs and profits cannot be more than 15% of total plan revenue (so there’s enough dedicated to funding pt’s benefits)
- Part D services is calculated separately
47County-lvl benchmark
- $$ CMS intends to pay the insurance company for providing care in a specific location
- Amount differs for each county bc CMS decides which location needs more care
- Based on geographics, demographics, avg Medicare spending at the county
- This is why you need zipcode for Medicare plan finder
48Bonus payment
- extra $$ CMS adds to the base rate payment for high quality care
- Bonus payments for 4-5 stars: extra 5%
- Bonus payments for 3 stars: extra 3%
49Rebates
- plans that bid under the benchmark receive extra $$
- Rebate $$ given is a percent (~50-70%) of the difference btwn the bidenchmark
- Plans with higher star rating/quality gets a higher rebate amount
50Risk adjustment
- modifies the base rate to reflect each enrollee’s health status
- Lower risk score = pt’s expected costs are lower than avg
- Ensures capitated payments for insurance company accounts for the expected cost for each patient
51Accountable Care Organization (ACOs)
- system of delivering care (patients) and receiving payments (insurance company)
- Penalizedewarded for negative/positive outcomes
- ACOs diff from CCOs, but very similar and will be used interchangeably for the scope of this class
52Veterans Health Administration (VHA)
manages health network and facilities for veterans
53Veterans Benefits Administration (VBA)
gives certain benefits and services to veterans and families
54National Cemetery Administration (NCA)
manages cemeteries and burial services for veterans
55Eligibility for general healthcare benefits
- Served in active military/navy/air service (honorable discharge)
- Enlisted after 9/7/1980 or entered duty after 10/16/1981
- Current/former member of the Reserves/National Guard
- Exposed to toxins/hazards while serving
56Disability rating
each disability is rated as % of impact (has protocol), all disabilities are used in a chart to calculate a total scoreating
57Eligibility for community care
- Enrolled in or eligible for VA healthcare
- Obtained approval from the VA healthcare team before care
Also at least one of the criteria in the additional list
- service isn't provided or not at needed standard at any VA facility
- state doesn't have full service VA facility
- in-network care isn't in best medical interest
- nearest VA facility over 40 mi distance requrement and lives in {AL, MT, ND, SD, WY}
- nearest VA facility over 30 min drive
58Eligibility for outpatient care
- veterans with disability ratings of 10%+ and/or in Priority Group 1 have no copay
- veterans with disability ratings of less than 10%+ have copay for non-service related conditions
- Priority Group 2-8 have copay for OTC and non-service related prescriptions
59Priority groups
- affects access to and cost of care
- Changes for person if income changes or service-connected disability worsens
60Service connection
- awarded due to disability/death in active military service
- Establishes eligibility for VA benefits
61Medal of Honor
- highest military decoration awarded for gallantryisk above and beyond call of duty
- Priority Group 1
62Purple Heart
- awarded to those wounded/killed in action
- Priority Group 3
63pharmacist role benefits at VA
- can practice in any US state, regardless of state license
- has prescriptive authority
- get PSLF and Education Debt Reduction Program