1individual differences and assessment
humans are better in groups
we need the capacity to asses and predict differences
crucial in order to be able to choose the person that is best fit for our needs ( hunter, provider, emotional support)
2introduction to individual differences
differential psychology = dissimilarities between or among 2 or more people
person centered, looking for qualities/characteristics within person that help understand behaviour
3**Cattell and concept of mental test (1890)**
worked with Galton to measure inherited characteristics
measure mental ability of college students
interested in ability of "normal" people
we are different on the inside
need to measure outside in order to recognise differences
differential psychology
psychometrics
4WWII and intelligence tests
the general mental ability "g" (general mental ability)
who should and should not attend candidate school
after war used for jobs
5g ocentric model
tendency to understand and predict behaviour of workers simply by examining 'g'
6**Varieties in individual differences**
cognitive ability
physical ability
personality
interests
knowledge
emotion
7**Fundamental assumptions in applying Individual Differences Model**
1. adults have variety of attributes that are relatively stable over a period of time
2. people differ with respect to those attributes
3. relative differences among people on these attributes remain even after trining
4. different jobs require different attributes
5. these attributes can be measured (KSAOs)
= knowledge , skills and other characteristics
8Taxonomies of abilities
=name giving
9Fleishman's taxonomies
52 abilities divided into broad categories
1. cognitive abilities
2. physical abilities
3. perceptual motor abilities
10physical and mental age
physical and mental age are different (more you grow the "smarter" you are )
not true after 18 25 y/o
true for children
knowledge is accumulative but intelligence is not
intelligence is the ability to learn
11IQ
people consider the terms intelligence, IQ, cognitive ability and mental ability to be synonyms for one another
12intelligence quotient
IQ is a historical terms that stands for "intelligence quotient"
term is popular with laypersons but not generally used by scientists
mental ability and cognitive ability are current terms that scientists often use interchangeably
cognitive ability and mental ability often refer to specific abilities ( memory or reasoning)
intelligence refers to general intellectual capacity ( "g" GMA)
13intelligence as g
intelligence as 'g'
involves the ability to reason , plan , solve problems
comprehend complex ideas
learn form experience
14g and job performance
'g' is an important predictor of job performance
correlation prediction and performance = .51 (average)
↑ job complexity = ↑ predictive value of general intelligence test
( if you become a cleaner does not matter if your IQ is high , when you become a surgen it does matter )
higher intelligence in this case it is a mediator
more important in complex jobs moderator
15Carrol's Hierarchical model
fluid : ability to learn
crystallised : the amount of books
they correlate ( more intelligent tend to gain more knowledge)
different categories are correlated but they are different
16**Sensory abilities**
vision
touch
taste
smell
hearing
kinaesthetic feedback
17Psychomotor abilities
also called sensorimotor or motor abilities
physical functions. , movement , associated with coordination , dexterity and reaction time
goes down after 40
more difficult to learn
18Fleishman's psychomotor abilities
arm hand steadiness
manual dexterity
finger dexterity
control precision
response orientation
rate control
reaction time
19The five factor model
1. Conscientiousness ( responsible , persistent)
2. Extraversion (sociable , assertive)
3. Agreeableness (cooperative , trusting )
4. Emotional Stability (secure, calm )
5. Openness to experience (curious, creative)
20Practical issues associated with personality measures
1. faking
self presentation
social desirability
21**Additional proposed individual differences**
1. skills
2. knowledge
3. competencies
4. emotional intelligence
22skills
practiced acts
technical and non technical
23knowledge
collection of discrete but related facts and information about particular domain
tacit knowledge → "street smarts"
procedural knowledge → " how"
declarative knowledge → "that"
24Competencies
set of behaviours in accomplishing various activities
combination of individual difference characteristics
knowledge, skills and certain behaviour → competency to teach
feedback looks at them individually
25Emotional intelligence
awareness of own and others emotions
controversial construct
26tests
= objective and standardised procedure for measuring a psychological construct using a sample of behaviour
GMA exists because we say it exists
not tangible
look at a sample of behaviour to determine it
27speed tests
speed tests have rigid demanding time limits
provide greater variability among candidates
issue relevance to job
28power tests
no rigid time limits
there is a point you come to your threshold and past this point no amount of time will make a difference
29bias
situation in which a given test results in statistical errors if predictions for a subgroup
30fairness
value judgement about actions of decisions based on test scores
31culture
system in which individuals share meaning and common ways of viewing events and objects
influence of culture and subculture on tests
the four animal tests ( dog unclean)
32**Procedure of assessing abilities**
1. cognitive ability tests
2. personality
3. emotional intelligence
33cognitive ability tests
allow individuals to demonstrate why they know , perceive, remember , understand or can work mentally
multiple tests
34battery
Getby battery test most known
35personality
1. screen out tests → identify psychopathology ( rule out narcissistic)
2. screen in tests → identify normal personality ( NEO PI , PCI , HPI)
36emotional intelligence
controversial construct with continued research investigations
link to Big 5 , cognitive ability and work outcomes
ability based EI measures have lower overlap with B5 personality measures
self report EI measures overlap strongly B5
37**Situational Judgement Test**
present candidate with written scenario then ask candidate to choose best response form series of alternatives
38important characteristics :
job related
well accepted by tests takes
reduced adverse impact compared to other devices
39staffing decisions
associated with recruiting, selecting, promoting, & separating employees
40predictive validity
ability to predict future job performance, job related learning ( such as amount of learning in trining and development programs ) and other criteria
41Incremental validity
value in terms of increased validity of adding a particular predictor to an existing selection system
what combination of tools to use for greatest predictive ability at lowest score
most effective assessment programs
what test and procedures might act as substitutes for other test and procedures
42Cognitive ability and tests
intelligence as "g"
involves the ability to reason, plan , solve problems comprehend complex ideas and learn form experience
43work samples
measure job skills by taking samples of behaviour under realistic, job like conditions
44Integrity testing
= quality of being honest , relaible and ethical
45overt integrity testing
ask questions directly about past honesty behaviour ( stealing )
as well as attitudes towards behaviours ( employee theft )
e.g. There is nothing wrong with telling a lie if no one suffers harm ( T/F) ?
46personality test integrity testing
test that infers honestly and integrity form questions dealing with broad personality constructs ( conscientiousness reliability and social responsibility)
e.g. Would you describe yourself as impulsive
47Interviews
1. Structured interview
2. situational interview
3. unstructured interview
tend to cover job knowledge , abilities, skills , personality and person org fit
48Assessment centers
collection of procedures used for evaluation
49typical characteristics
assessment done in groups
assessment done by groups ( assessors)
multiple methods of assessment employed
'feel' of relevance
50e.g. assessment centers
e.g. AC for flight attendants
group task : 'craft' an abstract concept form field of service
language test
role play / simulation task (negative situation on board )
51Controversial Assessment Practices
Geography
assumes traits can be asserted form various characteristics of a person's handwriting
Polygraph
machine that measures person's physiological reactions and signals deception
52Utility Analysis
assesses economic return on investment of HR interventions like staff training
utility analysis can adress the cost benefit ratio of one staffing vs another
53Utility SDy
the SD for performance in a simple environment vs professional
54Staffing practices on firm performance
high performance work practices
include use of formal job analyses, selection from within for key positions and use of formal assessment devices for selection
staffing preactices have positive associations with firm performance
55Cut score or cutoff score
specified point in distribution of scores below which candidates are rejected
raising cut score will result in fewer false positives but more false negatives
strategy for determining cut score depends on situation
56***Establishing cut scores***
Criterion references cut score
considered level of performance and find test score corresponding to that level
Nor referenced cut score
based on some index of test takers's scores rather than any notion of job performance
57Feelings of unfairness regarding Staffing strategies
initiation of lawsuits
filing of formal grievances with company representatives
counterproductive behaviour
58Staffing model
1. comprehensiveness
2. compensatory
59comprehensiveness
enough high quality information about candidates to predict likelihood of their success
60compensatory
candidates can compensate for relative weakness in one attribute cut scores through strength in another one , providing both are required by job
61clinical decision making
uses judgement to combine information and male decision about relative value of different candidates
62statistical decision making
combines information according to a mathematical formula
63Hurdle system of combining scores
**Noncompensatory strategy:**
individual has no opportunity to compensate at later stage for low score in earlier stage
Establishes series of cut scores
64score banding
Constructed from multiple hurdles so candidates who don't exceed each of the
minimum dimension scores are excluded from further consideration
Often set up sequentially
More expensive hurdles placed later
Used to narrow a large applicant pool
65Compensatory approach
Multiple regression analysis
Results in equation for combining test scores into a composite based on correlations of each test score with performance score
Cross validation
Regression equation developed on first sample is tested on second sample to determine if it still fits well
66Subgroup norming
Develop separate lists for individuals in different demographic groups who are then ranked within their respective group
In general, subgroup norming is not allowed as a staffing strategy
67Score banding
Individuals with similar test scores can be grouped together in a category or score band
Selection within band can be made based on other considerations
Score Banding is controversial