1 is a form of discrimination that violates Title VII, the ADEA, and the ADA (EEOC). It is defined as unwelcome conduct based on race, color, religion, sex (including pregnancy), national origin, age (over 40), disability or genetic information
harassment
2Harassment becomes unlawful when:2
1. enduring the conduct becomes a condition of employment
2. the conduct is severe or pervasive enough to create a work environment that a reasonable person would consider intimidating, hostile, or abusive
3Types of harassment 2
Quid Pro Quo
hostile work enviroment harassment
4: harassment resulting in tangible employment actions/ submission to or rejections of unwelcome sexual conduct is used as a basis for employment decisions
Quid Pro quo
5 are generally those with an economic effect on employees and job applicants, such as not being fired, being demoted, not being promoted, or a change in pay or economic benefits.
Tangible job consequences
6when the presence of harassing conduct in the workplace harms an employee’s employment environment, making the environment hostile, offensive or abusive./ unwelcome sexual conduct unreasonably interferes with an individual’s job performance or creates an intimidating, hostile, or offensive working environmen
Hostile work environment harassment
7Victims of harassment include:
Direct targets of the offensive conduct
Anyone else reasonable affected by the conduct
8The individual harasser is not liable for paying for the harm caused to the persons who are harassed. Employer is automatically liable for quid pro quo harassment by a supervisor if it results in things such as:
Termination
Failure to promote
Failure to hire
Lost wages
Employer liability in term of harassment
9 Employer is automatically liable for quid pro quo harassment by a supervisor if it results in things such as: 4
Termination
Failure to promote
Failure to hire
Lost wages
10 if the employer knows or should have known about the harassment and fails to take action to stop it
For harassment by a co-worker or a nonemployee liability
11Employer might be liable if the harassment creates a
hostile work enviroment
12The employer may not be liable for hostile work environment harassment if it can prove: 3
It took reasonable steps to prevent harassment
It took reasonable steps to correct the misconduct
The employee failed to take advantage of any preventive or corrective opportunities provided by the employer
13Employers can be liable for hostile work environment harassment committed by contractors, visitors, or customers onsite if:
It knew or should have known about the harassment and it failed to act decisively
14It is also unlawful for an organization to retaliate against any employee that alleges harassment
Retaliation claims to harassment:
15Generally speaking, there are three logical elements to a retaliation claim 3
Employee protected activity – employee informs organization that he/she believes harassment is occurring
That employee experiences an adverse action
There is strong evidence of a causal connection
16Defenses to harassment claims
Prevention: create a policy that defines harassment, outlines penalties and procedures, protects employees from retaliation
Prove at court that conduct was an isolated incident
Prove that employee did not indicate that conduct was unwelcome (specifically for SH)
Prove that “victim” provoked harassment through his/her own conduct
17not frequent or severe enough to cause unreasonable interference with work performance
Prove at court that conduct was an isolated incident
18 term used to refer to unauthorized reporting or disclosure of confidential information in institutional settings to protect the public interest. Employee conduct aimed at exposing wrongdoing that has negative consequences for the public, not just for the organization’s employees (not just retaliation against their employer)
Whistleblowing
19steps outside the approved channels of communication to disclose information to an audience who normally would not be entitled to it
Whistleblower:
20Public interest includes 5
Life
Health
Safety
Environment
Wasting tax dollars
21: steps are taken to bring conduct to light
active whistleblowing
22 refusal to participate in wrongdoing
Passive whistleblowing
23Reporting of misconduct in whistleblowing can be either be from:
internal or external sources
24Whistleblowing criteria: 3
Is the whistle-blower acting in the public interest?
• Is the whistle-blower acting in good faith?
• Has the whistle-blower exhausted internal channels?
25Whistleblower laws protect employees who report employer conduct
that harms the public. Most of the protections for whistleblowers are found in state laws. Several federal laws also protect whistleblowers. THE major protection in the laws is that employers may not retaliate or otherwise discriminate against a whistleblower.
Whistleblower laws: Protection
26Whistleblower statutes- federal:
Three general categories
Occupational, environmental, nuclear safety
• Transportation
• Consumer and investor protection
273 categories
protected activity
materially adverse action
Whistleblower statutes- federal:
28: Mostly cover violations of public health, safety, and welfare laws, and consumer and financial laws. Some states also provide protections to state employees who report gov’t waste, mismanagement or ethical violations. Prohibited employer actions vary state to state
Whistleblower state laws:
29Prohibited conduct for whistleblowing 11
Firing or laying off
• Blacklisting
• Demoting
• Denying overtime or promotion
• Disciplining
• Denial of benefits
• Failure to hire or rehire
• Intimidation
• Making threats
• Reassignment affecting prospects for promotion
• Reducing pay or hours
30Who is protected under whistleblower laws? Questions: 4
Is the Complaining Individual Actually Covered by a Whistleblower Law?
• Does the Potential Whistleblower’s Complaint Concern a Covered Law or Public Policy?
• Was the conduct reported properly?
• The Genuineness and Reasonableness of an Employee’s Belief in the Impropriety of an Employer’s Conduct
Note there is a scorecard to track this (slide 12)
31Prohibits adverse action against a public employee who:
• in good faith reports a violation of law by the employing [city] or another public employee
• to an appropriate law enforcement authority
Texas whistleblower acts
32Genuinely believe that a law has been broken. The belief must be supported by subjective and objective data
In good faith:
33Appropriate persons to report to under the Texas Whistleblower Act: 2
A Law Enforcement Official
• Federal, State, or Local official who is believed to regulate under or enforce the law alleged to be violated
34Logically, internally-focused whistleblowing is preferable to externally- focused. So, how do we encourage employees to internally report wrongdoing? Organizations DO HAVE cultures and these are very real even if we can’t touch or see them
Whistleblower programs:
35: The set of beliefs, values, and norms, together with symbols and personalities, that represents the unique character of an organization, and provides the context for action in it and by it." - Gareth Morgan
These patterns are stereotypic assumptions, inventions, and/or discovered by employees
• When a pattern works or when people THINK it works, it becomes part of the “institutional memory”
• These patterns are then taught to new organizational members through formal and informal processes
Organizational culture:
36What feeds a whistleblowing culture 7
Vigilance
• Engagement
• Credibility
• Accountability
• Empowerment
• Courage
• Options
37Barriers to whistleblowing: 6
A lack of trust in the internal system
• Unwillingness of employees to be "snitches"
• Misguided union solidarity
• Belief that management is not held to the same standard as workers
• Fear of retaliation
• Fear of alienation from peers
38What should we deal with whistleblowing 5
Have a formal policy and formal reporting mechanisms
• Have a clear and well-communicated chain of reporting, perhaps including an ombudsperson
• Have a clear and enforced policy against retaliation
• Lead by example – from the CEO on down
• DEAL WITH offenders when found and do so in unambiguous ways
39The Congress recognized that employees face a lack of employment policies that accommodated their roles as parents and caregivers, and that employees with serious health conditions lacked job security. In particular, Congress noted that women were disproportionately affected by the lack of leave policies because of societal gender imbalances when it comes to parenthood and other caregiving responsibilities.
Why (Family medical leave act) FMLA?:
405 purposes for FMLA
Balance employees’ workplace obligation with their family needs
Allow employees to take reasonable leave
Allow leave while taking into account employer’s legitimate interests
Reduce discrimination in the workplace against women because of maternity-related leave and family caregiving responsibilities
Promote equal employment for women and men
41covered employer for FMLA 3
Private Employers, 50+ employees
• State & Local Governments, regardless of size
• Public Education Institutions,regardless of size
42eligible employee for FMLA
1. Employed at least 12 months
2. Have at least 1,250 hours of service in the prior 12 months
3. Worksite has at least 50 employees within 75 miles
43Up to 12 weeks of leave for: 4
• employee’s own illness
• a close family member’s illness
• a qualifying exigency arising out of a close family member’s status as a military member on active duty
• the birth, adoption, or foster care placement of a child (“bonding time” leave)
44Up to 24 weeks of leave for:
• Military Caregiver Leave
45 Your own or a close family member’s physical or mental conditions along with being inpatient care or continuing treatment.
Serious health conditions under FMLA
46Intermittent leave: 2
medical need
Qualifying exigency leave (to address non-medical issues related to family’s member deployment)
47Medical need 3
• Employee’s own serious health condition, or
• To care for a close family member with a serious health condition, or
• To care for a covered service member with a serious illness or injury
48general notice explaining FMLA provisions and procedures
Covered Employer General Notice Obligations
49 an employee is not required to expressly tell the employer that the leave is for FMLA-qualifying reason the first time the employee request it. 30 days in advance of the leave or as soon as practicable.
Employee Notice Obligation
50Employer obligations During leave 2
Cannot require an employee to perform work
Maintenance of benefits
51employer obligations after leave 3
Job restoration at the same or equivalent position
No retaliation
Recordkeeping requirement